Episode 6

Access Undone: The Collapse of Special Education [Episode 6]

In this final episode of Access Undone, I try to outline the ways I would reverse the damage that has been caused in the last decade by the Department of Education and NCSE. I explore three solutions and argue that if all three were implemented, it would save the agencies from being part of the 21st century's greatest education scandal and, even possibly put them in the same definition of Ireland's most famous minister, Donagh O'Malley.

Transcript
Speaker:

Welcome to access on done.

2

:

The collapse of special education.

3

:

I special podcast from unsharp dot Nash.

4

:

This is Simon Lewis.

5

:

A teacher and principal for over 20 years.

6

:

In this series, I look back over the

short history of how children with

7

:

additional needs have slowly but surely

been cast aside by the education system.

8

:

I argue that much like the crimes of the

Catholic church on children, where the

9

:

scandal of the 20th century, that how the

state is treating children with additional

10

:

needs will be the scandal of the 21st.

11

:

During the Aon debacle.

12

:

The department of education

run a number of webinars.

13

:

To explain the process to principals.

14

:

I attended one of them.

15

:

And I sat in my office, staring at my

zoom screen with over 30 of my colleagues.

16

:

There was a nice man and woman

from the department of education.

17

:

Who explained that there was a court

ruling that meant that schools would

18

:

now be responsible for filling out the

education profile for the Aon form.

19

:

He explained that they had run a pilot

in several schools and that everyone

20

:

was really happy with dot pirate.

21

:

And there was very

little workload involved.

22

:

He thanked us all for our cooperation.

23

:

When it came to question time.

24

:

I spoke up.

25

:

I explained I was one of the so-called

pilot schools and I told them how long

26

:

the form actually took to fill out.

27

:

Much longer than the 20 to

30 minutes he had advertised.

28

:

I explained that I had actually

surveyed several schools and none of

29

:

them were very happy at all with this.

30

:

I asked the room.

31

:

Had anyone else, any thoughts

on it or had they been involved?

32

:

It's a very odd feeling.

33

:

Seeing 30 sets of eyes looked

down after you say something.

34

:

And you just know.

35

:

They are letting you drown.

36

:

The guy from the department told

me that my complaint was the

37

:

first he'd heard about this.

38

:

He'd been to lots of schools in the pilot.

39

:

And that everyone.

40

:

He had spoken to.

41

:

I was happy.

42

:

Over the last few months.

43

:

I've charged.

44

:

It had the department of education and the

NCSE have slowly, but surely made things

45

:

worse for children with additional needs.

46

:

I argued that as soon as the

recession came in:

47

:

children that were hit the hardest.

48

:

And when we emerged from the

emergency these same children

49

:

remained rooted in austerity.

50

:

Where the resources that were taken

away from them were never returned.

51

:

The NCSE never criticized

the government for failing to

52

:

fund their service properly.

53

:

And in fact, their CEO at the

time, Teresa Griffin welcomed their

54

:

budget in 2012, which included

a 15% cut to resource hours.

55

:

Instead, they invested ways to

save money by cutting resources.

56

:

I am convinced the new Brunswick

model was dropped once they

57

:

realized it actually costs more

than what they already had in place.

58

:

The massive expansion of what

they call autism units without any

59

:

research into how they actually

benefit children and using them.

60

:

Nevermind the possible ethics of

putting children into something called

61

:

units and providing minimal support

for them when they are enrolled.

62

:

We also saw how the NCSE did everything

they could to rid themselves of any

63

:

responsibility to any individual

child through the set allocation

64

:

model and instead forced schools to

perform the miracle of the loaves

65

:

and fishes to resource children's

needs with ever decreasing supports.

66

:

When there plan to not have any details

of children risked being upended by

67

:

a court ruling, which would've seen

them forced to identify the needs of

68

:

children for the assessment of need.

69

:

Aided by their friends and the

department of education, as you heard,

70

:

just there, the representative bodies,

which we discussed in a previous

71

:

episode on the unions, which we also

discussed in a previous episode.

72

:

They managed to wangle their

way out when schools were gaslit

73

:

into doing the work for them.

74

:

In 2023, they, again, tried to pull the

wall over school's eyes by removing the

75

:

criteria for special allocation teaching

hours after it was revealed that they

76

:

couldn't get the data from the HSE.

77

:

Uh, small uprising from parent

groups, advocacy groups, and a few

78

:

teachers was again, gotten over

by the support of their friends.

79

:

Most infamously from the IPN who told

their own members how wrong they were.

80

:

Those inventing a new educational term.

81

:

Called quantum.

82

:

Which as I found funny, could be

defined as a unit of the smallest

83

:

amount of something, usually energy.

84

:

At the same time, the HSE

failed to meet the needs of

85

:

tens of thousands of children.

86

:

When it came to speech and language,

occupational therapy, mental health,

87

:

psychology, psychiatry, and so on.

88

:

And in many cases, the only service

that was available to any child with

89

:

additional needs was their school place.

90

:

As you can see the link between

the states treatment of women

91

:

and children in the 20th century

supported by an independent partner

92

:

in the form of the Catholic church.

93

:

And now the 21st century is treatment

of children and their families.

94

:

This time supported by

an independent body.

95

:

The NCSE the last decade to me is a

dark mark on our education history.

96

:

What's worse to me is that much like

the crimes of the 20th century, what

97

:

empowered the state and its partners

for treating children in the way they

98

:

did was compliance through silence.

99

:

People that spoke up were often ridiculed.

100

:

Isolated.

101

:

Ignored.

102

:

And told that they were

the only ones complaining.

103

:

And everyone.

104

:

else was happy.

105

:

However, despite the last decade, as

I said, at the end of the last episode

106

:

in 2024, the NCSE came out with a

process which they called new for

107

:

resourcing special needs assistance.

108

:

Right now they're rolling out the red

carpet for us explaining how it works.

109

:

Perhaps we're about to see the

seeds of hope for children with

110

:

additional needs from the NCSE.

111

:

I've reached the point of the

podcast now, where I feel I

112

:

need to offer some solutions.

113

:

If you've listened to this show for a few

years, you might remember an episode I did

114

:

shortly after the newest CEO of the NCSE.

115

:

John Carney took the reins of the NCSE.

116

:

I given that I'm just big, loud mouth

with a microphone and a few ideas.

117

:

I don't expect anything I

say to ever hit his desk.

118

:

But for those of you that are interested.

119

:

I'm going to give you an updated

summary of those thoughts.

120

:

I read back over my ideas.

121

:

And to be honest, I now disagree

with at least one thing I had

122

:

argued for a couple of years ago.

123

:

However, there's one idea.

124

:

That I really liked.

125

:

When I was discussing the,

special education, teaching

126

:

hours, the allocations, and

it was during a conversation.

127

:

I had on the radio with

Karen Cudahy in Newstalk.

128

:

Well to tell the truth.

129

:

It came from the national principal's

forum, in the first place, but Karen

130

:

coulda, he made a really good analogy.

131

:

It was a nice, simple idea.

132

:

Which emerged after those set allocations?

133

:

I just said, and 20, 23, and I had the

job of speaking to Karen Cudahy on news.

134

:

Talk about it.

135

:

And he came up with the analogy

that to me, made it make sense.

136

:

To the man on the street.

137

:

The national principal's forum

recommended that rather having all

138

:

the complicated, meaningless and an

accurate algorithms that decided what

139

:

special education resources to award

to children in schools, the principals

140

:

would simply out outline the supports

they required for the school year on.

141

:

These would be provided.

142

:

They would do this on the system called

pod, which is the primary online database.

143

:

We do like our acronyms and

whatever it was put in pod.

144

:

That's what we would get.

145

:

And Karen could, he asked me.

146

:

Would it be similar to how

people filed their tax returns?

147

:

Um, that is one decides

how much tax they declare.

148

:

And if something looks a little

bit fishy, Then it's investigated.

149

:

And to me, it was a really good analogy.

150

:

There are only 3000 primary schools in

Ireland and we have lots of data on them

151

:

already that is used for the allocations.

152

:

Their size and their dash

status are two indicators.

153

:

Literacy and numeracy scores are

terrible indicators, but I will

154

:

concede that they also exist and

they are the only other variables

155

:

now used for allocating resources.

156

:

The key variable missing are the

actual needs of children in the school.

157

:

The national principal's forum suggested.

158

:

The principals would simply input

what the children in the school need.

159

:

Now, before you poopoo this idea and

came, the principals would take the

160

:

Mickey out of the whole thing and

applied for ridiculous amounts of

161

:

hours, way beyond what they need.

162

:

Just hang on for a minute.

163

:

And hear me out.

164

:

I don't think a school principal should

be expected to just pick a number out

165

:

of the air and pop it in the system.

166

:

The NCSE already has a system

where a school inputs, the

167

:

level of need of all children.

168

:

When they're applying for a view of their

resources, there would be nothing that

169

:

difficult about using that documents to

give a reasonable calculation of what

170

:

hours each child's need equates to.

171

:

They've had that they had that

before:

172

:

So let's say my current set allocation

in my school is about 200 hours a week.

173

:

That's go with $200 a week.

174

:

It isn't my allocation.

175

:

By the way, before you start going mad.

176

:

And let's say I filled out the

form on a calculated 205 hours, but

177

:

I decided to apply for 250 hours

a week for just for the crack.

178

:

Well, that should raise alarm bells.

179

:

If I applied for 250 hours, when

I should, when the calculation

180

:

said I should be a brown 205.

181

:

And I should expect to have

that evaluated and reviewed.

182

:

The document could be used to

calculate the allocation of SNS as

183

:

well as this, with the same system.

184

:

And in some ways it already does.

185

:

If I need an extra SNA or two

in my school, I have to seek

186

:

review of my current resources.

187

:

Ultimately the department and

the NCSE has seven years of

188

:

data on the Set allocations.

189

:

So it would be extremely easy to

get this system up and running.

190

:

With only 3000 schools and over

200 people working in the NCSE.

191

:

I think this could be managed

very easily and very quickly.

192

:

There were lots of

advantages to this model.

193

:

The main one is it takes a lot

of bureaucracy out of the system.

194

:

We don't need all those people

sitting in their offices and they

195

:

can now work directly with schools.

196

:

It also would stop the crazy horrible

system, which has been christened

197

:

the cluster games by principals.

198

:

This model would mean that schools

would receive an allocation to the

199

:

nearest full teacher and no more

fractions of hours will be necessary.

200

:

However that aside, I don't believe this

model alone would fix special education.

201

:

There's a reason why this

model isn't already in place.

202

:

And this is because we already

know the state and the NCSE is

203

:

not providing enough supports to

children with additional needs.

204

:

It is likely to cost the giving

children, exactly what they need.

205

:

We'll be more than double of

what they're giving already.

206

:

We need to look at ways to

systematically alter the education

207

:

system insofar as possible.

208

:

So you're going to have

to hear me at this one.

209

:

Too, but I think we might have.

210

:

Maybe too many teachers and SNS

working in special education right now.

211

:

Now, hopefully you haven't spelt your

hot cup of coffee all over yourself.

212

:

Hearing that did that big mouth Lewis,

just say we've too many teachers and

213

:

SNS after everything he said about

not having enough supports in schools.

214

:

Sorry for shouting.

215

:

I'm getting onto myself.

216

:

Anyway, let me reverse a little before

I go on and get you back to your coffee.

217

:

We probably don't have too many per se.

218

:

But we have too many working in

contexts that they shouldn't be.

219

:

I believe we're actually missing another

profession within our profession.

220

:

Most developed countries have these as

standard in their classrooms these days.

221

:

And that position.

222

:

Is the teaching assistant position

or the TA, as it seems to be known in

223

:

most other countries that have them.

224

:

What is a teaching

assistant you might ask.

225

:

And how is it different to a

special education teacher or

226

:

a special needs assistant?

227

:

Well, the teaching assistants is someone

who is the second adult in a classroom.

228

:

Who supports the teacher with all of the

things that a PSAT or an SNA doesn't do.

229

:

For example, a teaching assistant

can sit with a group of children

230

:

in the classroom and help at work.

231

:

A teaching assistant can sit outside

the classroom with a child who has

232

:

maybe has some sensory needs and needs a

little bit of time out of the classroom.

233

:

A teaching assistant can cover

the class for a very short time.

234

:

If the teacher is on their break or is

talking to a child that outside of the

235

:

classroom or sorting out an incident that

happened on yard, a teaching assistant can

236

:

take care of display, work photocopying,

and so on in a way they are the position

237

:

that the SNA originally was a general

second pair of hands in the classroom.

238

:

The SNA position has become

specialized on children's care needs.

239

:

So we need the teaching assistant to

look after the non-car needs of children.

240

:

I feel so strongly about this, that

if someone was to ask me the first

241

:

thing I would do, if I were the

minister of education, if I had a

242

:

magic wand, Well, you know what?

243

:

My first one would be to

separate church and state, but

244

:

my number two would actually be.

245

:

A teaching assistant in every classroom.

246

:

I really mean now my second thing that

I would ask for, if I was a minister

247

:

for education will be to have a

teaching assistant in every classroom.

248

:

The impact of a teaching assistant in

every classroom, I would argue we'll

249

:

do more for children with additional

needs than any other measure, except of

250

:

course, separation of church and state.

251

:

But that is for another day.

252

:

And honestly, I do believe the separation

of church and state would have a massive

253

:

impact on special education in Ireland.

254

:

Anyway, having teaching assistants would

allow special needs assistants, have the

255

:

time to upskilled to be able to offer

basic care services such as OT and SLT.

256

:

I really realize this is in the

plans for S and A's from the NCSE

257

:

already, but I can't see where they

will get the time to do these things.

258

:

Without someone like a teaching assistant

to take care of a lot of what used

259

:

to be known as secondary care needs.

260

:

You might think could be done.

261

:

But I have another bit of secret

sauce to not only pulling the NCS.

262

:

I E out of the Meyer, this

step will probably have a

263

:

massive effect on the H S E.

264

:

If you talk to most infant teachers in

the last couple of years and ask them,

265

:

what is the biggest issue you face?

266

:

They will likely tell

you one of two things.

267

:

One is a huge speech and language issue.

268

:

And the other is anxiety.

269

:

And this is where wraparound

services need to be on site.

270

:

There are several countries where

it is entirely normal to have an

271

:

onsite psychologist in the school.

272

:

I went to Finland last year and I went

to a small school of around 200 pupils.

273

:

They had a psychologist two days a

week, shared the bigger school nearby

274

:

of about 300 pupils who had the

psychologist for the other three days.

275

:

Most finished schools have full-time

psychologists, social workers on nurses.

276

:

And just in case you're rolling

your eyes at the relieving.

277

:

Even Scandinavian, loving that

you seem to hear all about why

278

:

is it always the Scandinavians?

279

:

Get it rice.

280

:

There are other places provinces

in Spain and the Netherlands also

281

:

have this as standard and actually

sometimes better than Finland setup.

282

:

Can you imagine the positive

impact on Irish primary schools?

283

:

If we had these now basic services, I

think about all those pilots going on

284

:

in certain counties, which simply need

to be rolled out to all primary schools.

285

:

I do understand that like Finland,

we have a huge amount of small

286

:

rural schools, but Finland managers

very well with clusters of schools

287

:

sharing these wraparound services.

288

:

And if we had these people in our schools,

I can guarantee you, you would see the

289

:

waiting lists for therapies, counseling,

psychiatry, dropping to manageable levels.

290

:

Very quickly.

291

:

I would argue we would

sort had so many issues.

292

:

We would end up saving more money than

we currently spend dealing with the

293

:

issues when children get older, such

as the impact of early school, leaving,

294

:

teenage mental health and so on.

295

:

I think the NCSE could, uh, would be

well capable of managing a system like

296

:

this, the school inclusion model, which

they were thinking of promoting a few

297

:

years ago was something like this.

298

:

Their therapies pilot was happening

in Wicklow ankle dare until COVID

299

:

times, and these were the, and

this was the seeds of this idea.

300

:

I'm not really suggesting anything

particular wild here, anything I've

301

:

said here, I think is pretty sensible

and so much maybe conservative.

302

:

However, at the moment, the

NCSE isn't quite there yet.

303

:

However, since the Starship recording

this podcast, they look like they

304

:

might be starting to sow the seeds.

305

:

A few weeks ago, the NCSE published

the revision of the guidelines for

306

:

schools applying for an SNA review.

307

:

And to be honest.

308

:

It's not that it's very different

to what was there before.

309

:

In fact, it's not very different at all.

310

:

But it's how it's being rolled out.

311

:

Isn't really that bad.

312

:

And I was very, very early days,

but if this is the beginning of

313

:

things to come, it is possible that

the scandal of the last gate decade

314

:

may be on its way to being fixed.

315

:

Of course, there is a very long

way to go on the NCSE structures

316

:

are still quite fractious.

317

:

For example, if you're applying for SCT

supports and SNA supports, you have to

318

:

deal more or less with two completely

different sections of the NCSE who won't

319

:

know a single thing about each other.

320

:

They need to untangle the layers of

bureaucracy that they built over the last

321

:

decade with all of the office staffs.

322

:

I get them out front

facing around the country.

323

:

However, these already signs

do look slightly positive.

324

:

The question is how long will

it take for the unraveling and

325

:

rebuilding to take to happen?

326

:

This episode is going out just before the

20, 24 general that action and whatever

327

:

party is in charge of education and

whatever minister falls into the role.

328

:

I was special education.

329

:

If this continues to exist, I hope it

is a row that is taken very seriously

330

:

with a decent minister who genuinely

cares for children with additional needs.

331

:

I would hate for it to be given

to someone who sees it as simply

332

:

a platform for a sexier portfolio.

333

:

I believe the minister who manages

to fix special education will be

334

:

held with the same celebrations

as we do for the likes of dun MRT.

335

:

You brought in free second

level education in the:

336

:

He is still widely considered to

be the best minister for education

337

:

in the history of the state.

338

:

So the question for the next minister

for education is will they do a donor?

339

:

Or will they like so many before them

stick with the compliance of silence

340

:

and the destruction of soundbites.

341

:

As for the NCRC, after a decade of error,

parable damage that was done to children

342

:

and those working with them will the

seeds, they just planted continue to grow.

343

:

There's so many people I'd like to thank

for their support in writing this series.

344

:

And it's probably appropriate.

345

:

If not disappointingly predictable.

346

:

That I can't tell you their names.

347

:

The people that contacted

me, contacted me anonymously.

348

:

I just fear for what might

happen if they went public.

349

:

And in some ways for this series,

I was simply the messenger.

350

:

The onshore.net podcast is written

and produced by me, Simon Lewis.

351

:

If you'd like to hear more of my thoughts

on primary education in Ireland, you

352

:

should subscribe to my maiden mist

on Shaw dot Nash slash subscribe.

353

:

If you've enjoyed the podcast, please

consider reviewing it on your favorite

354

:

podcast player, as it will help

other people find it more easily.

355

:

Until next time.

356

:

Thanks for listening.

357

:

And we'll see you again soon.

Next Episode All Episodes Previous Episode

About the Podcast

Show artwork for Anseo.net - If I were the Minister for Education
Anseo.net - If I were the Minister for Education
An Irish Primary Education Podcast

Listen for free

About your host

Profile picture for Simon Lewis

Simon Lewis